Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

Small

Price: 5.99

Medium

Price: 7.99

Large

Price: 9.99

Shake

Price: 9.99

Frappe

Price: 11.99

Sundae

Price: 9.99

Stuff Your Stanley

Price: 12.00

Sawyer Free Library Half Pint

Price: 6.50

Brioche Ice Cream Sandwich

Price: 8.99

Barq's Root Beer Float

Price: 9.00

Coke Float

Price: 9.00

Diet Coke Float

Price: 9.00

Dr Pepper Cream Soda Float

Price: 9.00

Dr Pepper Float

Price: 9.00

Fair Life Chocolate Milk Float

Price: 9.00

Mexican Coke Float

Price: 9.00

Orange Fanta Float

Price: 9.00

Sprite Float

Price: 9.00

Black Velvet Eclipse (Collab w/ Nocturne)

Black cocoa ice cream with red velvet cake chunks and cream cheese frosting swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Boston Cream Pie (Collab w/ Flour Bakery + Cafe)

Rich custard ice cream loaded with chunks of Flour Bakery + Cafe's famous Boston Cream Pie Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 12.99

Pumpkin S'mores

Pumpkin Marshmallow ice cream loaded with house-made graham cracker cookies, mini marshmallows & chocolate ganache Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Pistachio Baklava

2024 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Roasted pistachio butter ice cream loaded with house-made pistachio baklava pieces Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts

Price: 10.99

Apple Cider Donut (Collab w/ Downeast Cider)

Vanilla ice cream loaded with house-made cider donuts & cider infused salted caramel Donuts & Caramel made with Downeast cider donut reduction *contains no alcohol Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Apple Pie

Apple cinnamon ice cream loaded with chunks of apple & house-made graham cracker crust & cinnamon infused salted caramel Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Brown Butter Cornbread

Brown butter ice cream loaded with house-made cornbread pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Cereal Milk

Fruity Pebbles steeped ice cream mixed with colorful cereal marshmallows. Colored with all natural Blue Spirulina! Contains: Dairy & Soy

Price: 10.99

Chocolate

National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate Contains: Dairy

Price: 10.99

Cinnamon Churro Dough

Cinnamon brown sugar ice cream loaded with cinnamon churro dough chunks Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Coffee - "Xtra Xtra"

Iced coffee ice cream. Extra Cream. Extra Sugar. Contains: Dairy

Price: 10.99

Cold Brew Oreo

Our bold cold brew based ice cream loaded up with Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Cookie Dough

Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Cookies & Cream

Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Corner Piece

Brown butter chocolate ice cream mixed with homemade crispy brownie corner pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Hand-Packed Pint

Price: 10.99

Mintsanity

Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy

Price: 10.99

Orange Cardamom

Cardamom infused orange vanilla ice cream Contains: Dairy

Price: 10.99

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Brown sugar buttercream ice cream with housemade oatmeal cream pie chunks Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Party Animal

Strawberry Nesquik ice cream loaded with frosted animal crackers & Funfetti cake Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Pastel de Nata

Vanilla bean custard ice cream loaded with chunks of house-made pastel de nata & cinnamon salted caramel Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Rest in Pieces

Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream loaded with Reese's cups, Reese's Pieces & PB Swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Peanuts & Soy

Price: 10.99

Ritzy AF

2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (1st Place) Salted Butter Cracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Salted Caramel Brownie

Salted caramel ice cream loaded with house-made brownie pieces & salted caramel swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Price: 10.99

Salted Peanut Butter Oreo

Salted Peanut Butter ice cream loaded with Oreos & peanut butter swirl Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts & Soy

Price: 10.99

Strawberry

National Award-Winning Strawberry: NAICA Red Ribbon Rich strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction Contains: Dairy

Price: 10.99

Vanilla

National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Classic, creamy vanilla ice cream made with all natural Madagascar Vanilla Contains: Dairy

Price: 10.99

Vegan Coconut Oreo

Vegan coconut ice cream loaded with GLUTEN FREE Oreos Contains: Coconut & Soy

Price: 12.50

Vegan Cookie Butter

Coconut based cookie butter ice cream loaded with speculoos cookies Contains: Coconut, Gluten & Soy

Price: 12.50

Vegan Purple Haze

Coconut based Ube ice cream loaded with house-made vegan chocolate hazelnut bark Contains: Coconut & Hazelnut

Price: 12.50

Vegan Vampire (Collab w/ Vampfangs)

Vegan coconut ice cream with "bloody" cherry swirl, toasted almond chocolate bark & candied cherries Contains: Coconut, Almond & Soy

Price: 12.50